It actually reads as though you agree with most of them, if not all. And neither in BR. I am actually quite knowledgable of swing and wc, and see no difference between your post above and BR or AT. Again, this is identical to AT, and 'good' BR (not the step-by-rote-crap). We agree on all points, thus far. But, the descriptions do not imply a secondary skill. The fact that it is a primary skill is a base for my inital point, exactly. I don't follow your logic, here. Why do you assume that there is a distinctive separation? I have danced this seamlessly for decades; classes, comps, TC, etc. with no problems...or demerits. Why should there be a difference?