Amen and hallelujah, tt. You've been around DF forever, so I'm sure you remember some of the ... energetic conversations I used to have with DFers who were against allowing grinding/club style dirty dancing here.
To me, dance is dance. Find your style(s.) Dance.
To me, that's different than labeling. To me, it looks like a new dance form is emerging. Why not celebrate that?
Love this one, as well. Both of these dancers do the basics so,so well,and, when you least expect it, throw in some styling or extras (incredibly difficult stuff) matter-of-factly. It's really gorgeous.
I think there's a difference in that the arguments, around performance tango, are about HOW to execute tango patterns and to what music. (ETA: Or which patterns are appropriate to use where.) In WCS, the discussion is about WHETHER to execute WCS swing patterns and if so, how many. To me, these are two different things.
Either way, as I said earlier, dance is dance. There is no rule out there that says there's a finite number of dances and they've all already been invented. It's okay if WCS evolves into something else. But if it doesn't look like a duck, waddle like a duck, quack like a duck, etc, I have to start to wonder if it's a duck. Just sayin.
Mixed feelings about this one. The dancing is great, of course. I just think that the style of dancing is pretty much the same for both songs, even though the two songs are very, very different. Something a little more down home bluesy would've felt better to me, with the second song. I don't think either of them was feeling the second song. *sigh*
Here's an example of what Mr4S was talking about over in ballroom yesterday. Both beautiful dancers. Great moves. But they look out of sync, as if they're dancing AROUND each other instead of WITH each other. Can't put my finger on why I feel this way.
the arguments, around performance tango, are about HOW to execute tango patterns and to what music. (ETA: Or which patterns are appropriate to use where.) In WCS, the discussion is about WHETHER to execute WCS swing patterns and if so, how many.
If you are talking about our current Argentine Tango, "there are no patterns."
People have preferences about what kind of music to dance AT to: traditional or not, basically. And that same discussion occurs with WCS. "It doesn't swing."
Another discussion point is about how relevant performances are to social dancing. I think the same thing applies to WCS. Some people don't distinguish between stage tango / fantasia and what you might do at a milonga. Where I dance WCS looks like WCS. I've peaked into a few swing "events" and thought, what the heck? Let alone what people do in competitions or exhibitions.
WCS has very few rules, really, but more than AT. The is a Swing Dance Council that attempted? to define the "essence" of West Coast Swing and provide a basis for judging in competition. Patterns are taught to get people dancing in both cases. (yeah, there are patterns in AT, but we pretend there aren't just like we pretend an "open embrace" is an "embrace")