jon said:Master & Commander. Weir does not capture the scope of Patrick O'Brian's marvelous work, and barely touches on the complexity of the Aubrey-Maturin relationship at its core. But within the constraints of a Hollywood movie, he's done a fine job.
Considering the amount of material in that series, and the fact that not everybody in the theatres will have any sort of background about Napoleonic-era naval practice that's hardly surprising. I'm looking forward to it anyway.
I'm pretty much of the opinion that novels generally should not be made into movies (LOTR notwithstanding) as there is just too much material there. Some of the best movie adaptations have been of short stories eg Bladerunner. The length is right.
Cheers
Sarah