In response to OP’s questions, and to (hopefully) assist future DF readers with their shoe selection process...yes, I bought my shoes from overseas. When we did our 3 intro lessons I wore regular sandals bcs they were the only open toed shoes I had that buckled around my ankle & would stay on (I mainly wear slides in summer). Then when we did the 6 (I think I said 10 in a previous post but it was only 6) beginner lessons, I switched to a pair of t-strap character shoes I still had from the last play I was in, & they worked better than the sandals. Studio recommended suede soled true ballroom shoes if I decided to continue in the social foundation program, so I ordered several $20-$40 pairs from amazon in different styles & sizes (all 2” heels). My street shoe size is US 9.5 regular width, & after reading lots of customer reviews on Amazon I bought sizes 8.5 and 9 to try. I got my new pro’s evaluation of the ones that were comfortable enough to wear, so he could tell me which ones fit properly and explain why they needed to fit a certain way, & returned the ones that didn’t work (yay for amazon’s free returns). The 8.5 size fit best. When I practiced at home, I used a different pair than I wore at lessons, bcs our hardwood floors at home aren‘t nearly as nice as the studio floor & I didn’t want to damage the lesson shoes.
As I neared the end of my 14 social foundation lessons & prepared to start bronze program, I tried on the VeryFine dance shoes carried & sold by my studio. The studio only stocked one style of smooth/standard & one style of Latin sandals, & they were very uncomfortable on me. After making numerous phone calls, I discovered that NO other place in my city carried any ballroom shoes, so I couldn’t try anything on without driving 90+ minutes (grump grump grump). So I started studying the shoes of the ladies at my studio who were there for lessons a lot, and who appeared frequently on the studio’s Facebook page as comp participants. Many of them had shoe bags with “IDS” on them, so I looked up what that was: International Dance Shoes.
Next I did research online about “best ballroom dance shoes” & got all the expected names: Ray Rose, Supadance, Aida, Werner Kern, a few others. International was in the category of “really good but not absolute top of the line, midrange price, definitely sufficient for non pros.” I read a whole lot of reviews of IDS shoes, & purchasers’ descriptions of their various sizing & styles & heel types...also their return policy & procedures, since they’re in the UK.
And then I jumped in. If you’re going to participate in a sport, you need the correct gear. (You don’t wear $20 Keds for cross country running, for example, without risking injury & minimizing your chances of success.) I went to the IDS website & ordered a pair of Mia tan satin Latin sandals, US size 8.5, 2.5” IDS (flared) heels, & no customized features that would prevent them from being returned if needed. I also bought a shoe brush & plain tip heel protectors. SUCCESS! They arrived very quickly & I took them to studio before wearing them, to get Pro’s opinion. He said they fit perfectly. He was surprised I had spent that much for shoes I hadn’t tried on first...prob one of the first big hints to him that I was serious about learning dance. (The first night I wore them for a lesson, one of the more experienced students glanced at them & said, “so you went for the 2.5” heels?” I was impressed she could tell that in just a glance!) I still used a 2” pair from amazon for practice at home, but could tell a big difference in the heel heights, so occasionally I would wear my IDS shoes for short practice sessions.
I wrote a glowing review of my IDS sandals online, in which I said I would definitely be ordering my smooth shoes from them also. IDS emailed me to thank me for the review, and suggested that when I ordered the smooth style, to get a half size larger than my sandals. Very cool that they read the review & took the extra step of contacting me...no idea if other sellers do that, but it’s a first IME.
A month later, after Pro asked repeatedly “haven’t you bought your smooth shoes yet?” I went back to IDS website & ordered a pair of ICS Round Toe SingleStrap flesh satin shoes, US size 9, regular width, 2.5” IDS heels. (I also ordered another set of heel protectors, this time suede tip, bcs the plain tip ones are a non-skid rubbery plastic material that makes it hard for me to glide my foot forward on the long heel-toe steps. If I were a better dancer, they’d work fine, bcs my foot would be gliding just above the floor rather than on it, but I’m not.) As before, they arrived quickly, & Pro approved.
I’ve had the Latin sandals only 3 months & the smooth shoes only 2, so I can’t comment on how they’ll hold up over time. I had ZERO painful breaking-in period with either pair, which is a huge thing IMO.
As I gain more experience, I might try a US company & hope their shoes work as well for me as IDS, but since my focus was not on price or local availability, IDS was great for me.