Musicality in AT / Vals / Milonga etc

"I haven't been able to do this with my own body if my partner isn't doing it. It's like I need to play against something, and if the guy is just doing things with no change to the tone of his body, then I can't figure out how to do it with mine. Any help or suggestions out there?"

I went for a hike today instead of posting right away, so here's what I wrote earlier today...
I'm really glad that Peaches wrote about this, because I love this sort of thing, but as I say and write, it isn't something that you can outright give to someone else. It's a partnership thing. You can put it out there, but it can be like talking in an empty room if the other person "doesn't get it", or doesn't know what to do with it..
In other words, I can do things with my own body, which probably my partners can feel (connection, haptic communication, connection...), but what encourages me to keep doing that is when I feel them responding to what I do.

I guess my point is, just as you noted, it takes two people to make this happen.

Now, as to what you might do...

For instance, take the initiative with your own "changes of pressure". If you know there is a pause coming up, try to make him pause, or suggest that he pause by "making yourself heavy" ie give him more resistance.

Musical moment light and airy? Make yourself light and airy.
Has the music taken on a heavy quality?

You can use your own body to create tension, and release it as the man steps toward you. All you have to do is let a bit more pressure build up before you "take your step".

Try stretching out a step (make it last longer that it might be if you didn't respond to the music, when there is a "streched" out note in the music). Again you are "resisting" the impluse to complete the step earlier, and he should feel that. One place to practice this would be at the end of songs, where you sometimes get a scretched out ending. Then move it to specific phrases in the music.

You could also "stretch out" either the early or late phase of a step, and "make up the time" by compressing the other part of the step.

If the man is coming towards you, he almost HAS to feel this. In this way you are using your own connection to the floor.

Does the music feel circular to you (it often does to me towards the ends of songs when the bandoneon takes the lead)? If there is any angular momentum between you and your partner, make your self "post like" ie really ground yourself solidly over your standing foot, at the same time use your upper body to "suggest" that your partner keep goiing in that direction around you.

We've talked about how the steps of the molinete can be danced to go with the phrasing of the music, and to me this is just an extension of the thinking that you aren't "just following".

One of my favorites is when my partner begins to sway her upper body / shoulders during certain milongas. To me that says "Hey, let's play with this thing that's in the music".

Now, all of this may go unnoticed if the guy has never experienced this before. You have to go slow with this. You are making the dance equivelant of a convesational gambit.

Always try simple things a couple of times. Often, I won't notice something until the moment has passed. But I'll think, "Did she do that on purpose?" and try to be ready for it the next time, or do something along the same lines as we dance.

Another way to approach it is to get some sense of which teachers teach this sort of thing, and then try to figure out who takes, or has taken lessons from them.

"I swear it’s like I can feel the momentum flow up from the floor through his body and into his shoulders"

The teachers teach about "being grounded". The physicists (what few there are who get involved with dance) tell us that we move by pushing against the floor, and the floor pushes back against us. Through a heightened sense of "touch", or a "well toned embrace", and a body that is otherwise "still", or a combination of all of the above, you can now feel this.

I'd say, too, that you are describing the same sort of connectedness that we leaders talk about when we say we can feel our partners steps as if they were our own. THAT is the sort of feeling you want to give to your partner. And I'd guess you are doing that if you can feel it from him.

Other than trying some of the things I've mentioned, some of which I know may not be totally on the mark, unfortunately, in general you can't have really really good dances with people who aren't really really good dancers. And the more you learn about the really sweet stuff...
 
I can say from experience that unless a leader has learned at least a little of the above (actually hearing the music and learning how to express it in ways that make sense to his follower), it's actually quite a difficult thing to find ways to express oneself without disrupting the "flow" of the dance. After all, if you are the only one who is understanding your musical interpretation (leader or follower) are you really being musical?

This is from a post by bastet in anoher thread which may or may not be far form where it started.

It's been a while since we talked "musicality," and this thread has "etc" in the title, so I'm going to bump it, since my current thoughts are based on info I'm gleaning from research in swing and early rock 'n roll.

I'm going to leave this while I collect my thoughts, etc., but anyone have any new thoughts on the subject?

I sure agree with bastet.

When you have learned how to follow actively, and thereby take the initial impulse of a lead and take it to it's conclusion without having to be "carried" there or also getting away from your partner, a lot for time and space can open up for you, if you are dancing with a leader who is actually hearing the music and interpreting it in a comprehensible way.

I guess the question is, what exactly (more or less) is it that makes it comphrehensible?
 
...I guess the question is, what exactly (more or less) is it that makes it comphrehensible?

I've been thinking about this topic from the other thread. Bastet made an interesting distinction between feeling the music and being able to convey that feeling to ones partner as something understandable and reliable. Being understood and reliable gives the follower the ability and confidence to contribute her share of the dance.

To me it seems similar to the director of an orchestra. He has to have an idea of how he wants the music to be played, but he has to translate that idea somehow so the other musicians understand what he's thinking, and can participate constructively.

So, how is that done by leaders? I suggest that the leaders selects a feeling, inspired by the music, then demonstrates that feeling to his partner. He also stays with that feeling for a while, also inspired by the music, giving his partner time to recognize the feeling and respond to it.
 
Add to that the concept of "having tango" which is a completely separate thing from being a dancer. Having tango has to do with the connection to the partner because "tango" isn't the dance... its the relationship.

a) It sounds as if tango and dancing for you are different things.
b) It also sounds as if tango and argentine waltz was interchangeable for you.

Concerning the first item: relationship is not exclusive for tango at all. I started dancing at the age of 38. I have never danced before in my life, so for me dancing and tango was replaceable for many years. All those dances I learned later on (salsa, swing) do actually obey the same rules of connection, relationship, and leading. There is a word for it: projection. And Peaces described it in detail how projection works in her post. And of course ballroomies always confirm that their leading rests on the same principle. And also the BR frame depends on projection. And please note that the colgadas also use kind of a frame. Its a frame that is closed at your feet instead of the BR frame that is closed at the hips.

Concerning the latter. For me argentine waltz and tango are totally different animals. The styling, the phrasing, the vocabulary are different. But only because there is a fluent passage between these animals many inexperienced dancers use to dance tango to tree-four time.
 

Dance Ads

Advertise on Dance Forums Reach dancers, teachers, studios, event organizers, and dance-friendly brands. View ad options
Back
Top