Some random thoughts....
(warning: long rambling post. Definitely skip if you are easily bored or disinterested)
Where to begin.....
I definitely agree with msc, definitely the very tip of the iceburg. As an amateur who is trained in both styles, I can only tell you there is tremendous benefit to learning International Style. Since taking the plunge, my dancing took a quantum leap in almost every aspect.
I find International style definitely more demanding because it requires better footwork, technique, and balance to do well. Coincidentally, these are all things that make for better dancing in general. These also happen to be be qualities that are highly desirable in a competition setting. Once I competed in American style on a last minute whim (another story for another time :wink: ) after having been about 2 years removed from American style. Despite my long break from American style coaching and lack of preparation (no choreography! :shock: ), we did quite well and placed very favorably against dedicated American style dancers! In hindsight, all I did was execute simple patterns with better technique and that was enough to do quite well.
Yes, International style is a separate category from American. Knowing International style is essential if you want to compete in International but I also believe that knowing international style will also make you a better American style dancer. From my experience watching Professionals, I notice that some of the very best American Style pros are also accomplished International style pros and the difference is quite noticeable on the dance floor.
To me, it was initially difficult to learn. While I was considered to be a decent american style dancer when I started, I struggled with International style. For months I simply couldn't get the feel for it. Retraining my body was initially frustrating. To make it worse, it was nearly impossible to practice in a social setting since the predominant social style is American. So, I readjusted my strategy and perservered in spite of these challenges.
By observing numerous talented International Style pros easily make the transition to American style, it would seem that to transition from International to American Style is easily done for someone who is well trained in International. Personal experience tells me it can be rather challenging to go from American to International style, but the rewards are well worth the effort.
After a year of study in International style, movements that were once difficult to pull off in American style were now easily comprehended and executed with ease. I found Rhythm to be much easier to do and people commented on how sharp I made it look. I really started to enjoy Smooth even more than before and it became really effortless with the added balance and technique you learn in international (some might say it became extra smooth 8) ).
As far as social dancing, I was initially concerned that International style would take away from my enjoyment of social dancing and make it more difficult to lead since the predominant social style is American. While I was now able to dance socially in both styles, opportunities to dance International style in a social setting were few and far between. Gradually over time, greater quality of movement that comes from practicing International style made leading easier and somehow made previously "unleadable" patterns easily lead. Social dancing became even more effortless and fun.
Warning: Once you take the plunge, you may never go back :wink:
Back to lurk mode...