Do do we ever pay off the debt?

But since there is a shortage leaders in tango (in Western Europe), it unfortunately becomes the task of strong followers to drag weaker leaders onto the dance floor...
One of the guys that recently started in my scene started tango because he wore a suit to a Halloween salsa event and a lady there said you look sharp, should go to tango. It feels like the shortage of leads is a bit self inflicted sometimes where it takes so little to encourage leads from other dances to try tango but they just don’t stick around due to the culture shock
 
One of the guys that recently started in my scene started tango because he wore a suit to a Halloween salsa event and a lady there said you look sharp, should go to tango. It feels like the shortage of leads is a bit self inflicted sometimes where it takes so little to encourage leads from other dances to try tango but they just don’t stick around due to the culture shock
it’s funny how people want to make tango friendlier, when the actual culture of tango in BA isn’t friendly (relatively compared to other dances, also i know it depends on the milonga etc etc), so trying to make it more welcoming and friendly is going against the authenticity of it in an ironic way.
 
it’s funny how people want to make tango friendlier, when the actual culture of tango in BA isn’t friendly (relatively compared to other dances, also i know it depends on the milonga etc etc), so trying to make it more welcoming and friendly is going against the authenticity of it in an ironic way.
For BsAs' locals, or for visitors? Like a French waiter dealing with English and US visitors in Paris?

Many milongas internationally have moved beyond the 'authentic' myth of BsAs, unless playing some retro game. Many of us aren't even going to visit BsAs.
 
Bailango, why do you find it so hard to admit that pianistamediano is right?

About what exactly. He hasn’t been part of salsa scene or immersed in it.
If the parties for older and younger dancers were to merge, then older followers would have much! worse chances than it is the case in the tango scene.
Says who? Salsa worldwide is a lot more heterogenous than tango. Salsa is far more dance of the people than tango is.

My lived experience in salsa scenes do not match what is being stated here. People experience salsa through different mediums. So are formally trained (studio trained). Some are casual dancers and not trained. A lot like salsa for its music than dancing. There are those who are avid dancers. For some it is an opportunity to socialize (similar to tango). Different venues cater to different types of those with affinity to salsa. Festivals attending crowd is only a fraction of those that dance salsa socially. Among trained dancers there is a being component of performance team dancers.
 
when the actual culture of tango in BA isn’t friendly (relatively compared to other dances, also i know it depends on the milonga etc etc),

Actually I think it is friendly when the ratio of tourists to locals is lower.

If I had a local crowded milonga where 50 random new people showed up each week most of whom I'd never see again, I'd be selective too
 
For what it's worth, where I've danced socially salsa in restaurants/clubs, concerts, and community event venues in different areas of the country (minus my university years), the older salseros and salseras outnumber the younger ones (40+).

Since I began dancing socially - outside of university - my leaders were often 15-40+ years my senior. (Now, the range has reduced to more like 15-25 yrs older. :D)

In my experience, the youngest crowd (under 30) tends to dance more of the latin pop, reggaeton, bachata sensual, fast dominican bachata, zouk, huapango... Salsa is often viewed as an older dance person dance.

Though, salsa congresses, university clubs, and recent graduates seem to make/keep salsa relevant for young people by attending, hosting, and supporting community events and congresses.
 
Yes, all true. And this still doesn't disprove my point. We're getting somewhere...



This just supports my point — disregarding medical concerns or life getting in the way, if they're still getting dances and enjoying themselves, they wouldn't quit, or just go to an event where the demographic is older. Salsa is a younger woman's game.

You are insinuating that women quit because they stop getting dances. That’s not true. Most of the reasons for quitting has nothing to do with not getting dances. It is more to do with starting family, or outgrowing going out dancing till 2am during the weekdays. Salsa is more hectic danced to fast tempo music. At festivals the older women get as much dances as the younger ones.

Personally, I don't hear about followers in tango quitting in their 40s; it's more 50s or 60s or above. Then again, YMMV.
Usually people start tango when they are in 40s. Tango is more sophisticated and more difficult dance than salsa. Its slower tempo is more attractive to older people than salsa’s uptempo (for dancing)
I don't think you get what I'm talking about — I'm speaking specifically about venues in either tango or salsa with a mix of demographics. How the heck would age discrimination occur if they're all old already?? Beyond some age, the difference is academic. Maybe you could argue that men in their 60s would rather dance with women in their 60s than 80s, but all I've seen in tango events I DJed for with that particular demographic is that unless the woman/man is infirm or just a bad dancer, they dance just as much as everyone else.
There is no extra age discrimination in salsa than other dances or walks life. When a dancer isn’t good and old, you can’t blame age discrimination. That is true whether it’s salsa or tango.
Obviously, if we're talking about age discrimination, we must consider only events/venues where there is a good mixture of ages, what I would say spans at least 50% older and above. (For example, people in their 30s to people in their 50s).
20 year span isn’t wide spread. From dancing perspective those in 50s dancing with those in 30s is fairly common in all dances I know. When venue has a good mixture of dancers there generally is less discrimination.
I've seen a lot of those events in tango, and ceteris paribus, a leader will choose to dance with a younger follower. I've seen older followers that were great (speaking from personal experience) who sit down for an hour while younger followers dance almost non-stop.
In follower heavy scene that may be true. In leader heavy scene all followers are dancing. May be it is also challenge of not enough leaders to go around.

I recall you defending the right of people to dance with whom they prefer. While I have always argued for people doing their bit for greater good of tango community.
I've seen disgusting men in their 60s gravitate towards the pretty young things and I've seen them standing around, having their cabeceos ignored.

What do you mean by disgusting men in their 60s. What is disgusting about them ? Their age or they come across as creeps.

Their preference to dance with younger ladies is not too different that other types of preferences about whom to dance with


I've been ignored by older dancers because of my relative youth too. That's reverse age discrimination for you.

In my scene younger male dancers are popular with older ladies. Mostly because they happen to be good dancers in first place. There are milongas where I am the youngest dancer.

What kind of discrimination is it when a visiting dancer doesn’t get asked because they are not a known face.
When comparing tango to salsa, it's disingenuous to compare something like an """elite""" (lmao) marathon to a regular, local neighborhood party in Havana. The tango equivalent would probably be Club Sunderland. You'll see whole families go out there and dance with each other and their friends. Age isn't really a factor. So we should compare events with similar demographics.
Problem is the event types are very different in Tango and Salsa. It is not easy to make apples to apples comparison. That was my point. And when you can’t make apples to apples comparison, the rest of the comparisons (e.g. age discrimination) are harder to make.).

For my part, I only developed this opinion after speaking with tango followers who've danced salsa, bachata and/or kizomba.
You can’t compare experiences in salsa with those in bachata and kizomba. Bachata and Kizomba is a whole different world than salsa.

In my book to validate experiences and to make them count a dancer needs to be immersed in the scene to equal length and depth.

A salsa follower or leader talking about his/her experience at tango for a few months as a beginner after being a salsa dancer for 10 or 15 years is to be taken with a grain of salt.

Experiences as a new to the scene will be biased by having a decade of experience in different dance form. That controversy about zouk dancer and her first time experience at milonga in the NYC proves my point. While we who are immersed in tango scene know about cliquishness and snobbishness, her experience was more a failure of lack of understanding of Milonga (culture) and her friend setting her up for failure in first place.

They've told me stories about aging out of these dances, and they've danced everywhere from Cali to New York. They all mentioned that tango, despite existing age discrimination in some/many events, is still much kinder to them.
Did you ask them why ? What causes aging out?

It has less to do with being discriminated because of age and more to do having to keep up with younger women.

Unfortunately salsa demands a lot of athleticism from the followers than from the leaders. Most leaders in salsa tend to dance physically than musically. Many leaders in salsa won’t even step. The follower doesn’t have that luxury. This can wear out followers as leader after leader is putting them through wringer. Especially when they realise follower is a good dancer. They will try to throw kitchen sink of moves they know at her. Whether they have mastered leading them or not.
 
I think there is a difference between the studio dance social environment that is pretty much what you described and the broader salsa in the community social scene. In the US at least, there are a lot of events ran by local bars, outdoor events and such that often have a live band and are super open to the public and non-dancers. There is much of an everyone gets to dance attitude there. We even have a group in my local community that calls themselves fabuelas ( fabulous abuelas / grannies ) that have grandchildren and great grandchildren, are in 60s-80s and go out and probably get more dances at those events than young hot women.

Exactly. This was my point. The salsa (social dancing) universe is very wide and very diverse. Therefore you can’t say “In salsa x”. Among studio trained dancers too, there are those that will only attend mambo (on2) socials and those that won’t. Those that are more into social dancing and those that more into performance teams. Cuban salsa is a whole different scene of its own which mostly doesn’t mix with on1 or on2 scenes.

The salsa scene in Europe is very different (and tiny) than in North America, Carribean, and Latin America.
 
From the peanut gallery in the back...
Unfortunately salsa demands a lot of athleticism from the followers than from the leaders. Most leaders in salsa tend to dance physically than musically. Many leaders in salsa won’t even step. The follower doesn’t have that luxury. This can wear out followers as leader after leader is putting them through wringer. Especially when they realise follower is a good dancer. They will try to throw kitchen sink of moves they know at her. Whether they have mastered leading them or not.
Preach! (Sometimes I watch my leader and think - this is totally unfair. Why is he barely moving and I'm drenched in sweat? Or, does he really know how to do this move without hurting me?)

I appreciate the ones who move around a little too and understand technique enough to protect my shoulder joints and feet, so I don't have to go through the wringer and defend my own joints.

Albeit, the role of the follow is to be the picture to his frame, he can at least take a step in some sort of direction - occasionally and try not hurt me.

Climbing down off my soapbox...

The real debate can resume.
 
You also found salsa more difficult.. While most people find salsa far easier...
:p You'll hold that against me for the rest of my life. Maybe I'll find something else to rub your nose in, high Voleos? Colgadas, by chance? But you know I've successfully cleared the salsa hurdle. And I did it by way of playing music. And if we apply that criterion, maybe we can reach an agreement. And now, just to annoy you, I find European bachata sensual much more original than the so-called authentic bachata dominicana, which is currently experiencing a renaissance :p
 

Dance Ads

Advertise on Dance Forums Reach dancers, teachers, studios, event organizers, and dance-friendly brands. View ad options
Back
Top