He is a nice surprise to this season. He definitely is fun to watch. Knows exactly how to please the crowd.
I think Peta failed Nyle. He did a great job, but the choreo was way too hectic for a rumba. He did perform it well, it was more on her end... I think she understood that though. But it only being week 2, a slow rumba might have exacerbated any problems he had and he might have done worse. Way too much "contemporary."
Val/Ginger... come on. They only did about 30 seconds of actual dancing, and maybe 2-3 moves were actually samba. Everyone else I think did much better.
I think Jodie is the best actual dancer out there, but she has a pro in which people don't expect much of. I think they did a great job.
It was nice to see Doug Flutie get out of "Beginner's Hell" a bit, but I still didn't think much of that Paso. It is a very difficult dance for a newbie to pull off though.
Overall, I think I would have liked to see Geraldo for another week and see Mischa go. Even though he was terrible, he was still having a ball with it... and he had a sense of humor about his ability (and lack thereof) on the floor.
Peta absolutely failed Nyle. I heard last night referred to as the Great Choreography Robbery

was it just me, or was Peta dancing extra violently? Nyle danced it beautifully, but there wasn't much shade and light - he was whipping Peta around at warp speed through most of the routine, and I didn't see much rumba timing. That could, however, be due to the fact that maybe she didn't figure out how to teach him rumba timing? And especially with the song they had, there probably wasn't a ton of vibration for him to feel through the floor to pick out the timing.
The longer he's a pro on the show, the more and more time Val is spending dicking around at the beginning of his dances. I don't get it. Especially because Ginger is actually quite a good dancer.
I do really like Jodie and I think Keo is capable. I mean, when I noticed how basic the tango choreography was, I realized I didn't notice the first time I saw it because she actually made it look really good. HOWEVER. She will not make it through the season if she keeps having a meltdown every week. The fact that she lost it in week one doesn't bode well.
Doug, I love. Everyone kind of flung him off to the side, and for all the hype over Antonio and Von, he sure schooled the young bucks in how to work hard and persevere. Plus, neither Antonio nor Von are doing it for me at all.
I totally agree with you on the elim, though - at least Geraldo was having fun, which is what this is about. Mischa, see...that's a hard one. She doesn't look like she wants to be there, but apparently she's just really fragile and insecure and she just seems to feel like Artem isn't being very nurturing. But to me, it looks like Artem really is trying to make this a good experience, but she doesn't want any parts of it. And I don't watch the judges' critiques (since season 18. Because they don't make sense), but I saw her face fall and then she ran off camera. Artem quietly followed immediately. Not sure why, but this season is making me like him a lot more. Not that I ever disliked him, just saying.
Again, I really love Paige. But as impressive as he was, I'm not sure Alan came off very well last night. Camera mugging during the dance, first of all...and then in the skybox, he's all, "I'm sorry Mark is injured but THIS IS THE BEST NIGHT OF MY LIFE!" And then the fact that Mark kind of got relegated to just standing off to the side when he's the actual partner, not to mention the one that did all the work...that whole thing just didn't sit well with me. When Shawn Johnson had those times with Derek and Mark, no one got pushed to the side. Except maybe Brooke Burke, who tried asking inflammatory questions and got shut DOWN. Ah ha.
On the other hand...I thought Geraldo's dance was HYSTERICAL.