The long-term solution is dual-role dancing?

Feels the women who want to lead have an easier time.
I think so too, especially in small communities. But the in my opinion relevant point is that no one is prevented from taking beginner's classes with the guy next door. and if the guy next door isn't interested, then that's tough luck, for both men and women.
 
Watch your wording: When she started, she was "some" and I was "everyone"!
For consolation, here's an interview with a couple who are significantly more successful as event organizers. They started with the first "Totally in Tango" about ten years ago; today they organize professionally 14(!) such events per year, from a weekend to a full week, equipping and catering some others. Very friendly, there's no selection process, but more space because many participants are relative beginners in the "other" role.


 
... many participants are relative beginners in the "other" role.

Bit of a sticking point for me here; not that I'm advocating for banning beginners from events, because that would be ridiculous!

But while I'm happy to dance with beginners in my home milonga/s whenever I'm in a good mood, when I travel or attend an event, I do it because I want good, enjoyable dances with people who match me. Plus, it's not my community.

Though I have danced with beginners at pre-/post-party milongas organised in conjunction with events...
 
a couple who are significantly more successful as event organizers
I'm not sure that "more successful" is fair. As you say yourself, Totally in Tango prides itself on being open to all, so there is no required standard for either role. I'm not sure whether Melina's events have any formal entry requirements, but certainly my impression is that most participants are competent in both roles. They are targeted differently, and it's no surprise that one would have more events than the other.

Put it this way: I was told that I would be welcome at Totally in Tango despite being very much a baby follower who can follow steps and rebounds with varying levels of success but is still hopeless at following pivots. I disagreed with my readiness for any dual-role event and so haven't attended. I suspect I'm a year or more away from that.
 
Wow, how refreshing an attitude! I must see if I can fit one of their events into my schedule!
One of my friends went to a festival in Oklahoma last year called the Open Role Tango Festival and really had a great time. One of the organizers is doing another one in Boston in March. It's just called the Boston Open Role Tango Festival
 
Put it this way: I was told that I would be welcome at Totally in Tango despite being very much a baby follower who can follow steps and rebounds with varying levels of success but is still hopeless at following pivots. I disagreed with my readiness for any dual-role event and so haven't attended. I suspect I'm a year or more away from that.

A year of preparation to then deliver a passable performance - that seems more like a male pattern to me.
But double-role events are (currently?) aimed more at women (and a few good-natured partners?). Women are at a milonga anyway, and many lead "organically", so to speak, kind of musically moving their followers over the floor(*). My SO handles it that too; without any formal training, she'll take the lead in a tanda with me for a minute and looks what happens.

(*) I'm aware and get told by my SO, that some of the best leaders are women, but to be honest, these are still rare.
 
(*) I'm aware and get told by my SO, that some of the best leaders are women, but to be honest, these are still rare.
One of my teachers said in an after class tea session that with more women leading she kinda needed to also learn to adjust her following. In the sense that with a bulkier male lead she felt very comfortable and safe giving up her whole axis and doing things like leaning in more but with a lot of the female leads she couldn’t. She said that when she was learning to lead the metaphor her teacher used to always say was “channel your inner man” which probably isn’t very acceptable nowadays.
 
I'm aware and get told by my SO, that some of the best leaders are women, but to be honest, these are still rare.
I would say it's for sure true for milonga. Tango and vals, I don't know, but we certainly shouldn't underestimate the massive benefit of knowing how a great lead feels.
 
with more women leading she kinda needed to also learn to adjust her following
I was discussing leading with a female friend, learning to lead. She noted the obvious fact that women are built differently and 'they get in the way' when leading other women.

If you think about it, then body form does imply differences:rolleyes:
 
I know what great followers can feel like, but that that doesnt make me any good at following!
I don't think they are equivalent, though. Sure, experienced followers still have to learn leading skills, including navigation, but I think following experience is more valuable in learning to lead than leading experience is in learning to follow.
 
I don't think they are equivalent..
I also think so. I had to learn both roles simultaneously 26 years ago. My first teacher, who came from Uruguay, insisted on it. But every time I switched roles, my perception switched as well. I was never able to apply insights from one role to the other. For me, leading and following are two completely different animals. I therefore consider it nonsense when leaders are advised to learn the following role in order to optimize their leading skills. And one last thing: of course, I much prefer following to leading. But that might also be because I'm not a fan of that modern "active following" (Naveira). As a leader, I project (that is, I remotely control the partner's moves), and equally, in the following role, I want to be remotely controlled. Only then can I switch off my visual cortex and feel like foam on the ocean. I don't have to worry about anything then; I just float through the waves as if sedated.
 

Dance Ads

Advertise on Dance Forums Reach dancers, teachers, studios, event organizers, and dance-friendly brands. View ad options
Back
Top