Question to Leaders about Followers

..All the Golden Age orquestas are ..expressible if you change the shape.. and height of the embrace without changing its distance..
Excuse me if I slip back into the style thing. But all the Argentinian teachers I had advocated that you should only dance to a certain orchestra in a certain way. All Argentinian milonguero teachers honored d'Arienzo as their pillar saint, to whom one could only move appropriately in an apilado hold. All Villa-Urquiza teachers claimed Pugliese for their house musician, to whom one was only allowed to dance in Salón hold.
 
Excuse me if I slip back into the style thing. But all the Argentinian teachers I had advocated that you should only dance to a certain orchestra in a certain way. All Argentinian milonguero teachers honored d'Arienzo as their pillar saint, to whom one could only move appropriately in an apilado hold. All Villa-Urquiza teachers claimed Pugliese for their house musician, to whom one was only allowed to dance in Salón hold.
Maybe your teachers had accumulated too much knowledge?
In tango there is everything, and of course the opposite of it.
I'm pretty sure I dance differently to an early D'Arienzo than to a late Pugliese, but that's only because the music is different, not because it's a different orchestra. With an early Pugliese and a late D'Arienzo it may be different. And always in a close embrace.

Ricardo Vidort once told me that he taught everything he knew in eight classes. Then he told his students he had no more to teach them. They had to go practice on their own and develop their own style. They didn’t need more classes. He was right. Those who stay in classes for years want approval from the teacher and won’t practice on their own.

 
Last edited:
I still wistfully remember the times when guests at our milongas were asked about the longest journey. Usually there were four to eight English guys who regularly came with Ryanair for 5 €.
Sometime in the mid 1990's when Ryanair took advantage of deregulation of air fares within the EU and set up competing with the established airlines with flights from Manchester. Also a time when climate change wasn't even a consideration. Ryanair probably did more to cultivate movement and cultural exchange across and within the EU than anything else.

Nostalgia isn't what it was.
 
I think tango teachers have tried many, many variations of teaching. And until now none has had universal success, most of the time not even dancing at their own milongas is significantly better than elsewhere.

With CE, however, I think that it only works in the classroom if the leader has sufficient experience. Or if the teacher has outstanding skills, which by definition is very rare.
There's no universal solution because it's partly cultural. The teacher has to have the teaching skills to make the 'lesson' accessible by their students. It's not about AT, or waltz, or rumba, or samba; it's about explaining in a way that students are receptive. Of course, you're going to get some who can't make that cultural change; others will find it natural. Some will still like AT, but not want to do CE. That's up to them and their reasons. Some will choose not to dance with them; others may be more flexible.
 
Ignoring the outer fringes of the rarity of a social observer, or just seeking a hook-up, most are there to dance (there are other reasons). Yes, there may be selective choice of dance partner of those actively participating in the specific game, and here we're back to the request/response of cabeceo/mirada, but, as discussed at length in other threads, there's then the non-maskable verbal or walkaceo request. Sure, there are restrictive cohorts, and in some locales it's not socially acceptable (codigos) to request by any means from outside the cohort, but it's most likely about a milonga in a large, western, city - presumably 'central' location for tourists and probably with a younger clientele. Even a basic social politeness response to a stranger should get at least one tanda, or maybe at worst an outright rejection. But then, at least, you know. As a visitor, does that even matter? You're unlikely to return.
I think he said he returned to the same venue on the following night (or later in the week) and things were much better.
 
With CE, however, I think that it only works in the classroom if the leader has sufficient experience. Or if the teacher has outstanding skills, which by definition is very rare.
All the traditional milonguero teachers begin from the abrazo and work their way up from there. You don't need to be experienced to understand it; you do need to be experienced to make it work smoothly and efficiently though. And that can take years.
 
Sometime in the mid 1990's when Ryanair took advantage of deregulation of air fares within the EU and set up competing with the established airlines with flights from Manchester. Also a time when climate change wasn't even a consideration. Ryanair probably did more to cultivate movement and cultural exchange across and within the EU than anything else.

Nostalgia isn't what it was.
Yes, but I wouldn't boil it down to that. I was also impressed when in Copenhagen the staff at the entrance registered that we were from Germany and passed this on to the host for his announcement.
Likewise that the entrance fee for guests from Sweden got reduced by the bridge toll.
 
All Argentinian milonguero teachers honored d'Arienzo as their pillar saint, to whom one could only move appropriately in an apilado hold. All Villa-Urquiza teachers claimed Pugliese for their house musician, to whom one was only allowed to dance in Salón hold.
We are not, however, restricted to their canons. You can dance any and all Golden Age tango in a very close abrazo--from D'Arienzo to Canaro to Troilo to Pugliese. That's the way it's been done for decades. Of course, if you're into escenario, one does whatever one does on stage.
 
All the traditional milonguero teachers begin from the abrazo and work their way up from there. You don't need to be experienced to understand it; you do need to be experienced to make it work smoothly and efficiently though. And that can take years.
To be honest, for me "traditional milonguero teacher" is a contradiction in itself. Either "traditional milonguero" or "teacher".
I just don't expect dancers, who get reactivated after 30 years, to know what they are doing as teachers.
I haven't experienced it directly, but indirectly the results didn't seem convincing to me.
 
Yes, but I wouldn't boil it down to that. I was also impressed when in Copenhagen the staff at the entrance registered that we were from Germany and passed this on to the host for his announcement.
Likewise that the entrance fee for guests from Sweden got reduced by the bridge toll.
Depends where you were travelling from. At least on mainland Europe you could travel by rail (memories of those massive rail depots and sidings in the middle of the night). From the UK the basic problem was getting off this island on to the mainland without selling your body and soul to pay for an air fare.

Yeah, those bridge tolls. Sweden: the place the Danes go to tell themselves that Denmark is cheap.
 
All the traditional milonguero teachers begin from the abrazo and work their way up from there.
By 'traditional' I'd presume you meant Argentinian, so coming from the cultural melting pot of BsAs. So, initially picked out as something 'exotic' and 'forbidden' by those around the world who wished to learn AT. Let's not forget that these teachers would primarily have been good dancers but not necessarily good teachers.

It's certainly a good starting point: if you don't like it don't waste your time and money on more. But there's money to be earned from students continuing, and some may change their viewpoint and buy in. Overall it's beneficial for the future if more people continue with AT, so I'd prefer CE to be introduced as considered appropriate by good teachers who are culturally aware. Obviously, with social AT teachers, that's not going to be a standard quality of teacher.
 
The short answer is that, in London milongas, there are enough wannabe performers to disrupt the entire ronda. Those close to them have to take evasive action, then other have to evade the evaders ... This makes it impossible to really get lost in the connection and the music as the ronda moves unpredictably and sharply.
I understand wanting to avoid that!

Here, it's less "wannabe performers" and more leaders who dawdle while vast space opens up in front of them, step back against the line of dance even when they could advance, and dance all turns as sweeping movements that involve them either walking around the outside of the follower or projecting the follower into a huge orbit. Of late, another trend seems to be freezing in place for an entire musical paragraph; it's far more than a pause. It's all big, halting, and prone to retrograde motion. Unfortunately, that's how the dominant schools in town taught them, and as they're the dominant clique, they're at all the invitation-only events here . . .
Ronda of that type are buzz kills. More than followers it is other leaders that I kill my joy of dancing. I refuse to go to milongas where there are enough leaders that others want to evade, those who take more than two steps against line of dance when there is couple right behind, those who will take up space and not move along causing traffic jam behind them, and especially those that dance with sweeping movement hurling their follower around taking up space when the ronda needs to keep moving. The last types generally are open embrace dancers, don't particularly follow the music or display musicality, and will usually dance in place rather than keep moving. I had one such leader ahead of me last night. Everyone else was dancing in close embrace. He was the only one in open embrace, not moving with the ronda and using elaborate movement. He was taking place of two close embrace couples by himself alone. I simply decided to close up his space by which forced him to move ahead.

 
I often wonder whether followers who cannot dance with the traditional close abrazo have simply never learned how to do it or don't like being close to their partners? It's clear that some have never learned or have been taught only how to dance in a very rigid open frame, a bit like ballroom. I'm not so sure about the others. I generally try to select potential partners from among those who look comfortable dancing traditional AT.
I largely haven't had that problem. Either locally or when traveling. It is rare that a follower will choose not to dance in close embrace. That as been my experience. At last week's milonga, there was a follower that I wasn't familiar with. She was dancing in the couple right ahead of me in the ronda and in close embrace. When I was dancing the next tanda she was seated and eying me. After a couple of tandas, I cabeceo her and she enthusiastically accepted. She started in open embrace right away. There are some followers who might start in open embrace or slightly open one and then quickly get into close embrace after a few bars. Not this one. So we danced entire tanda in open embrace and she didn't feel responsive or fluent enough to the leading. Then later in the evening I saw her dancing with yet another lead and sure enough it was in close embrace. No idea why she decided I was the one to be open with :D

I find open embrace restrictive in that most followers who choose to dance that style are not responsive to lead signal in expected time, unless you are dancing with a really good follower. However those who are really good can follow both open and close. I have yet to meet a really good follower who can follow one well and not the other.
 
Well, that, at least, is encouraging. Friend who went to London recently, and who is well-known here as both a teacher and a host, said he was at a local milonga there and stood around all evening without getting a dance. That's rough. It can happen but it's not a fun way to spend the evening.
Him being a leader, I find that a bit strange in a big city like London. I am assuming the milongas must have at least 50 or more people. Something similar to me happen in Barcelona once. There were only 15 or 20 dancers in total. I think I danced only two tandas. Decided to leave early after hour and half. I had previously danced at other milongas in Barcelona and never had an issue.

Typical milongas in the cities that size or types I have been to have between 75 to 125 people rotating through the evening. The larger milongas can have 150 to 200+ people if space is large enough and milonga is very popular.
 

Dance Ads

Advertise on Dance Forums Reach dancers, teachers, studios, event organizers, and dance-friendly brands. View ad options
Back
Top