JournalInTime
Forum Master
No worries. Also: Thanks. It's rare that anybody apologizes for a misreading on the Internet!Ah, I see. I apologize for misunderstanding.
I've been taught by at least two – and I suspect three – teachers who applied ballet systematics to tango. It was interesting. On one hand, they were good at telling us how to create movements and avoid injury. On the other, they confused a lot of students by using ballet terminology (battement, chaînés, ronde de jambe, etc.) that didn't translate when they went to other tango lessons. Granted, that's an easy error to make in a francophone region!A lot of the attributes carry over, and ballet - because its main framework has been for a long time to teach - has a extremely well developed system of actually effectively training people. And that is something that tango very much lacks.
I've found it easy to dance with people who later told me they danced baladi, blues, kizomba, or samba de gafieira. My personal experience is that salseras are too wiggly and ballerinas aren't grounded enough. So I find that other styles vary in value.bellydance seems to translate well, as does brazilian samba.
Grounded is the big one! My coach constantly reminds me that tango is a "dance of the earth," not a "dance of the air." She keeps saying that I need to keep my knees softer, dance closer to and "in" the ground, and try not to look like a tall, floaty show dancer, because that's another style. I'm not 100% on board with the low, heavy look, but when it's totally absent in a partner (as I hinted at above), it's really hard to dance tango with that partner. The elderly Argentines at our local milongas all dance low, and stomp out their steps . . . you can see the canyengue.tango teaching in general does not seem to have a great toolkit to teach people how being grounded
Growing up, my best friend had four sisters; three were put into ballet. The local ballet school was full of girls I knew. My ex started in ballet at that time. My life and dance partner started in ballet. My (female) coach started her dance career in ballet. And when I list the last 10 women I danced with and know well enough to call friends, ~60% did at least some ballet.Another view would be that ballet is the most common training path that young women who enjoy dance and movement are exposed to.
So, I think ballet shows up in tango mostly because girls inclined to dance at all get shoved into ballet, and because they are inclined to dance, they grow into women who take up other dance styles later in life. Ballet isn't often consciously selected as good preparation for tango by future tangueras.
As long as you can filter out the unwanted. As I said, I find unfiltered salsa and ballet dancers to be iffy interpreters of tango, though certainly more stable and supple dancers. But as I journey through tango, I'm finding that the "missing piece" is more often tango interpretation than general dance athleticism. I'm slowly coming to regret my "Technique above all!" obsession, because it kind of steered me away from a lot of potential partners who were very musical but not very athletic.I don't think it really matters that much exactly which discipline one has done before - it's still a large advantage over not having done any.